***SPOILER ALERT*** BRAVE expectations

3 min read

Deviation Actions

Jerome-K-Moore's avatar
Published:
5K Views
With this online art community, we have a unique opportunity to connect with our kindred. We must avail ourselves of this experience, for it may never come again.

*****************************************************

So, I finally caught BRAVE on home video. I'd say that it's good, but well below the "high water mark" set by Pixar Studios over a decade ago. Sure, there's heart in this story, as well as humor. But absent is the innovation that has come to be expected of Pixar fare. Wonder. An impossible splendor that comes cleverly entwined with well-rounded characters and a sensitive core that causes the story to strike just the right resonant chord. The TOY STORY trilogy, THE INCREDIBLES, FINDING NEMO... These remain the brightest gems in Pixar's crown, but perhaps the studio's reign is at last beginning to fade? In Princess Merida we have a young girl coming of age, dissatisfied with her lot in life, in the midst of rebelling against tradition, her responsibilities, and her parents. Okay, so we've seen this before. What new twist can you offer? Not much. A spunky girl who can do everything better than the boys? Yawn. An old witch in a creepy forest? Seen it. A spell that goes all wrong? Seen that, too. Adventure ensues until the spell is broken, lessons are learned, and new bonding takes place. Shrek much? Pardon my cynicism, but you have to do better than that. The competition is gaining fast on you, Pixar. You only lead until you don't anymore. Just sayin'. Color me unimpressed. Mild thumbs up.
As always, your mileage may vary.
Cheers!
~JKM

© 2012 - 2024 Jerome-K-Moore
Comments56
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Log In
TonyDennison's avatar
I agree wholeheartedly.

The whole narrative structure of BRAVE has been explored Ad nauseam for decades. I wanted BRAVE to be Princess Mononoke in Scotland, but we in the west just have not the courage to explore the entire scope of human emotion and engagement. It all goes back to that old refrain that animation is for children, children must be protected from the crueler truths of human experience; like death and love/sex and so forth...

Also, Pixar has been owned by Disney since 2006. I'm not sure when development began on this film but I suspect that we'll be able to mark the Disney influence on Pixar's output... in the areas of concept and plot development/direction. All the films you mentioned were landmark films for Pixar; all of them predate the Disney purchase... of course, TS3 does not, however the narrative structure for that series was already established, so Disney doesn't get credit for that... ;-)